Apparently a fan wrote into the show with some Dan/Elliott/Stu slash fiction. The hosts were horribly scarred, and have demanded no more such fiction ever be written. Details of said story have been slowly leaking out over time. Apparently the story involved Elliott licking Popeyes grease off everyone's bodies.
We thought we could handle the slash fiction. But the one piece of slash fiction that we got, it was like the ending of Y Tu Mamá También: once they have the three-way and the two young men have a sexual experience with one another, they could not be friends anymore. Much in the same way, just reading a slash fiction piece with the three of us —
Stuart suggests retooling the Flophouse format. To wit: fewer bad movies, more pornographic movies, and instead of talking about the movie, to just masturbate as a group. Ultimately is rejected since they had already tried that once, with at best mixed results. (Episode 68: Teen Witch)